[Taxacom] Phylocode vs Linnean nomenclature, again
Curtis Clark
lists at curtisclark.org
Fri Apr 15 23:14:10 CDT 2011
> Hi Curtis,
> Here we go again with the "blame game", [...] The strictest of cladists have so abused
> the Linnaean system [...] Control freaks [...] sort of like rapists [...] the Hennigian counterrevolution [...]
I have to say you've outdone yourself here. If I wrote stuff like that,
I'd be ashamed.
> In any case, feel free to name all the clades (holophyletic taxa)
> you can document.
That's all well and good until they cross a grade boundary. Your system
notwithstanding, paraphyletic groups don't play well with others, and if
some clade-based taxonomists think they can't get what they want from
the existing system, why is anyone surprised that they'd make another?
--
--
Curtis Clark
Cal Poly Pomona
More information about the Taxacom
mailing list