New Universal Taxonomy Database

[Mary Barkworth]

It also duplicates several existing efforts, but some of those efforts
have not obtained the funding that they need to achieve their goals (so
far as I am aware).  It is a messy situation. Let us hope that they are
planning to work with other projects and not try to have a completely
different system.    

-----Original Message-----
From: Bill Shear [mailto:wshear at EMAIL.HSC.EDU]
Sent: Friday, July 05, 2002 9:55 AM
To: TAXACOM at USOBI.ORG
Subject: Re: New Universal Taxonomy Database


On 7/4/02 2:30 PM, "Ken Kinman" <kinman at HOTMAIL.COM> wrote:

> Dear All,
>    Has there been any discussion on TAXACOM of the Marine Biological
> Laboratory's new universal taxonomy database (the UBIO Project)?  The
MBL's
> monthly newsletter for April 2002 announced a $500,000 grant from the
Andrew
> W. Mellon Foundation to help support this comprehensive database.
>    WOW!!!  And here's a link to (and one sentence from) the UPI press
> release on Tuesday:
>
>   http://www.upi.com/view.cfm?StoryID=02072002-033846-5544r

And more from the press release:

                    "This scientific dilemma is compounded by the fact
that
taxonomy -- the science of classifying and naming organisms -- is
scattered
into dozens of specialties, each with its own often jealously guarded
way of
handling things. "Fish experts don't really care about sponges and the
dinosaurs, and so you have fish-based and ant-based and mammal-based
solutions," Remsen said. "Navigating all that information is hard
because
you have to re-learn the taxonomy every time -- there's no consistency
to
it."

This is rubbish--there are only 3 systems, and they do not differ by
much.
ALL animal taxonomy is governed by the ICZN, which you only have to
learn
once.  But of course you would have to learn the taxonomy of sponges as
a
new endeavor if you were a fish specialist--or any other kind of
specialist.
So you don't have to "relearn the taxonomy" every time, only once for
each
group that interests you.  What this guy is implying is that there is an
entirely separate system of naming and of categories for each
taxon--makes
you wonder about his capabilities for organizing this worthwhile
endeavor.

But hey--aren't they too late?  Nature and Henry Gee have already
decreed
that the Linnean Society is going to handle it....

Bill Shear